Since I just finished reading about Salem’s Lot, and watching the 1978 mini-series, I also gave the 2004 miniseries a whirl. (181 minutes)
Composer Christopher Gordon's site notes, "Salem's Lot premieres on the TNT cable channel on June 20th and 21st, 2004 to be broadcast throughout the summer and shown worldwide later in the year."
I’m going to tell you now, I liked it.
The less likable stuff:
I’m reading a lot of fans who absolutely hated this film, and probably with good reason. There’s a lot to hate here! In particular, the story is so heavily changed at unnecessary points.When King gave us the unabridged version of The Stand he pointed out that we would not find old characters behaving in new ways. Their behavior would remain consistent with what we found in the abridgement. I think that is what fans also expect of movies. We’re okay with new scenes, or even story changes – so long as characters remain consistent with who they are in the novel. But in this version, Father Callahan in particular is a very different character. And, for a movie that wanted to so honor King’s work, it doesn’t make sense to mess up the Callahan character, who is necessary for the Dark Tower.
Another example is the story of Dr. Cody. He is tricked into an affair, and then extorted. This is to combine another story from the novel – but it doesn’t work with Cody’s character in the book.
Some of the complaining about this movie is just ridiculous. One website whined that the movie’s narration is not read by Rob Lowe in the same voice that he acts in the movie. That’s because. . . he’s narrating!
Now, for what I did like. . .
1. I liked the references to other King works.
- The music in the background of the bar: Stand By Me.
- Rob Lowe also starred in The Stand.
- Andre Braugher, who plays Matt Burke also played Brent Norton in The Mist.
- Father Calahan is played by James Cromwell, who also played the warden in The Green Mile.
- Background as they search for missing children, “Shut up, Cujo.”
2. This is an all star cast! Donald Southerland, Rob Lowe both do great.
3.This version does a nice job of telling more of the back story than the original mini-series. It also doesn’t have that strange 70s tv feel. The narration quotes large passages from the book as the Lot is described.
4. I really like the Marsten House! The inside is delapadated, like a long forsaken building might be expected to be.
5. I like the dark, shadowy Barlow in this.
6. Oh, them Vampires are a nasty brew! Very nice. I like the way the vampires leap about and crawl naturally on the ceiling. A very nice, freaky, touch! They feel like real animals in human skin.
7. At points, this version is much closer to the novel. Not only is the narration drawn directly from the book, but the scene in which Barlow confronts the priest is very similiar. Allowing the vampire to speak is great, and Rutger Hauer (who plays Kurt Barlow) does it so well. He doesn’t turn into Bella L., or try and be anything other than Mr. Barlow. He is energetic, condescending and flat out mean. This is a scary Barlow.
8. It is neat when people get bit. For all the fear they have of getting gnawed on by a vamp, once it actually happens, the experience appears euphoric.
The review at 80's fear notes:
“The smaller touches often work the best, such as Petrie’s models now including Cenobites instead of the standard Universal monsters or the subtle way the abuse committed by the young mother against her baby is handled. Donald Sutherland is great as Straker, Dan Byrd is good as Mark Petrie, while Rutger Hauer and Andre Braugher give great performances in slightly underwritten roles that keep them offscreen too long. The Marsten house also appears a much more menacing structure, looming over the town, while 90% of the second half gets things right and manage to stay fairly close to the novel (at least until the stupid character change in Callahan, especially stupid given the character’s tales of the events following Salem’s Lot in the same year’s novel Wolves Of The Calla), the fifth of the Dark Towerseries.” (HERE)
The Music
Composer Christopher Gordon has a lot of information about the music in this mini-series(HERE)Asked if he read the book, Gordon replied: "By the time I came on to the project the film was nearing the end of editing. I haven't read the book and I think it is important that the composer score the film that's in front of him or her. There can be quite a difference in structure, interpretation and tone from the script by the time the director has shaped it and the actors, cinematographer and editor have brought their ideas to it. So the book is even further removed. The composer's inspiration and challenges are what's on the screen."
For this lavish production, Christopher has paired with internationally-renowned vocal soloist Lisa Gerrard, whose distinctive work with composer Hans Zimmer on Gladiator (2000) garnered her a Golden Globe. For Salem's Lot, Lisa jointly-contributed to three cues, which are represented on the soundtrack album as "Bloody Pirates, "Converting The Priest", and "Salem's Lot Theme". Lisa also composed "Salem's Lot Aria", with Patrick Cassidy, and "Free in Spirit".
Recorded between October and December, 2003 at the newly-constructed Trackdown Scoring Stage in Sydney, the score to Salem's Lot was brought alive by the choir Cantillation and the composer's regular session orchestra, Pro Musica Sydney. Gordon's score, whilst constructed around a diatonic key centre, derives a proportion of its material from a series of aleatoric cells and harmonic clusters used to form a structured montage. Thematically, his music is driven by a need to define strength in the face of sheer adversity, accentuating the nature of the evil that has overridden the Marsten House and which now pervades Jerusalem's Lot.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeletethe black haired young girl, the daughter of the mayor or a business man I think, is really pretty althought I don't remember her in the novel
ReplyDeleteby the way do you notice some similarities between this novel and Ghost story by Peter Straub?
i haven't read ghost story.
ReplyDeleteI've read it, but it's been so long ago that I remember nothing about it except that I liked it. A lot.
DeleteWell, a lot to talk about again.
ReplyDeleteFirst the good:
For whatever reason, Rob Lowe makes the perfect Ben Mears, you're right about Haur being a good Barlow, and watching his performance here it's easy to see why King thought he'd make a good Walkin' Dude. To be fair, Haur performance here comes closest to matching the idea of Randall Flagg I have in my head than any other actor, and that's saying something.
Likewise, Sutherland is good as Straker, and it's a shame all these actors aren't given better material to work with.
Which brings to the bad:
First the focus of the script. Salem's lot is not what you'd call an Old Man's Book. King was barely out of his thirties when he wrote it. Yet the stories focus on the past and the memories of it's older residence mark it out as a story who's adaptation calls for a mature hand, such as Richard Christian Matheson. In other words, not the guys responsible for goth girl film The Craft.
These guys are more interested in messed up goth teens, which explains the film's being littered with Twilight rejects. Unfortunately, they are not the story.
Then, there is Callahan. I note what you say about character consistency and how it's violated in the miniseries. I understand completely. To it's a clear demonstration the writers didn't care all that much about the story to bother about how they handled the characters.
In a way, this matter of consistency eplains my not liking Doctor Sleep as the direction it's going in isn't consistent with the characters. What makes it worse for me is King is writer who does care about the characters yet here he admits it was just letting off steam at general sequel dislike.
Anyway, one thing i did like about this version of Lot was the conclusion to the Susan character and the nice final scene between her and Ben. It's not perfect, yet it provides a more satisfying and bittersweet closure to their story, so much so that I'm willing to believe it should have been in the novel, give or take a rework or two (and no I'm not being inconsistent with my last paragraph, I happen to think the even the best stories are a combination of inspiration and invention and that even the best authors loose the narrative thread and have to substitute through conscious invention and that such moments happen not just in Lot but also It and 11/22/63. There is a difference in this view from necessary and unnecessary invention. That's my two cents anyway).
The only problem that i can see with such a sequence is that it still leaves the door open to all the Twiloight tripe we've been bombarded with in the last few years.
In fact, if he wants it, I now turn the floor over to Honk Mahfah, he's seen the Rifftrax version of Twilight, so that makes him more of an expert than I'll frankly ever want to be, no offense meant.
ChrisC
Not only did I see the RiffTrax version of "Twilight," I saw it without RiffTrax! I've seen all of the movies, and listened to all of the audiobooks.
DeleteThey are thoroughly mediocre, but I sorta get why people fall in love with them. Only sorta, though.
As for this version of "Salem's Lot," what I remember of it is that I enjoyed the parts of it that stayed close to the novel, and disliked the parts that didn't. I can't remember whether I liked Rob Lowe as Ben, but I definitely recall liking most of the cast.
Ultimately, I still think the novel has not been captured on-screen, so I'm guessing a third version will happen one of these days, and that'll be okay by me.
Final note: Chris ... man, you REALLY aren't looking forward to "Doctor Sleep," are you?
I'm really looking forward to Doctor Sleep.
ReplyDeleteYeah, i know, I'm like the Star Wars purist in the room. Uh-oh, now I've done it.
ReplyDelete(Stands Back as the endless fan tirades begin)
ChrisC
I could say many, many snarky things here, but I'll take the high road and just not do it.
DeleteIt's impossible to mess up an original because. . . we always have the original!
ReplyDeleteIf a painter painted OVER their painting, they destroy the original. But King books always exist in each state in our libraries.
Marcus
ReplyDeleteDoes anybody know what song is played in the background in the bar when Susan, Mike and floyd are having a discussion and Mike started to act crazy? Thanks.
Not I; sorry!
DeleteThanks anyway Bryant. Everybody is looking for this song but it seems that no one has a clue about it. I've been looking for it for almost a year but to no avail.
DeleteWell, if you ever find it out, pop back by here and give us an update -- you've got my curiosity piqued now!
DeleteI sure will man..I sure will. If I'll ever find it that is. I'm beginning to think that it's a random song they decided to put in the background of that scene.
DeleteMarcus.